The low-rate mortgage problem
Millions of homeowners have mortgages from 2020 and 2021 at 3% to 4%. Today's 30-year average is 7.11%. A cash-out refinance would move the entire balance, not just the new cash, to that higher rate.
The default example: a $450,000 home, $260,000 left at 3.25% with 25 years to go, and $50,000 needed.
| Monthly | Total interest | |
|---|---|---|
| Cash-out refi: $316,200 at 7.11%, 30 years | $2,127 | $455,755 |
| Keep mortgage + $50,000 home equity loan at 8.25%, 15 years | $1,752 | $157,419 |
Keeping the 3.25% mortgage saves about $375 a month and roughly $298,000 of interest. The refi figure includes $6,200 of closing costs (2%) rolled into the loan.
When a cash-out refinance does make sense
- Your current rate is about the same as, or higher than, today's rates.
- You want to drop PMI or switch from an adjustable rate to a fixed one anyway.
- You need a large amount, and second-lien lenders cap you lower.
- You'll stay long enough for the closing costs to pay off.
Otherwise, look at a HELOC or a home equity loan. Both leave your first mortgage untouched.
Costs to plan for
Refinance closing costs typically run 2% to 5% of the new loan: appraisal, title insurance, origination and recording fees. Rolling them into the loan means paying interest on them for decades. Also note that the cash itself isn't taxable income, and mortgage interest on it is only deductible if it's used to improve the home; see the tax rules.