HELOC vs home equity loan, side by side
| HELOC | Home equity loan | |
|---|---|---|
| How you get the money | Draw as needed | Lump sum at closing |
| Rate | Variable (prime + margin) | Fixed |
| Early payments | Often interest only | Principal and interest |
| Interest charged on | Only what you've drawn | The full amount |
| Best for | Renovations in stages, tuition, a safety net | One big cost, debt consolidation |
The example
$50,000 repaid over 15 years. The HELOC is at 8% with 5 years of interest-only payments; the fixed loan is at 8.25%.
- Home equity loan: $485.07 every month, $37,313 of interest.
- HELOC: $333.33 for 5 years, then $606.64 for 10 years, $42,797 of interest.
Despite the lower rate, the HELOC costs about $5,500 more because nothing is repaid for five years. If its rate averaged one point higher, the cost would reach about $48,500. Pay principal from the start and the HELOC would come out ahead. The low early payment is what you pay for.
Questions that decide it
- Do you need all the money now? Yes: home equity loan. In pieces: HELOC.
- Could you handle a payment that rises if rates do? No: fixed loan.
- Will you repay within a few years? Then a HELOC's flexibility usually costs less.
Have a very low mortgage rate? Borrowing on top of it with either option is often cheaper than a cash-out refinance.
HELOAN vs HELOC: the names
Lenders sometimes call a home equity loan a "HELOAN" to set it apart from a HELOC. Same product: a fixed-rate lump sum. So "HELOAN vs HELOC" and "home equity loan vs line of credit" are the same question this page answers. More on how the line works in what is a HELOC.